Many people say they have the best pizza in New Havens due to hard water, making the dough more elastic. It’s a fantastic beginning story; however, it’s now no longer what makes a pizza better than each different style of pizza throughout the country.
The dough goes through a prolonged fermentation procedure at most New Haven-style pizzerias. It’s refrigerated for a single day before bringing it to room temperature for baking, which leads to a denser and crispier crust. Speaking of crust, the coal-fired ovens are a part of the pizza magic. The intensely hot brick oven is liable for charring the pizza and giving it that excellent taste.
In the city of New Haven, Connecticut—home to Yale University and the birthplace of the hamburger—pizza is the most contentious subject of debate.
Well, in New Haven, it is pizza. The city has its style of pie that isn’t only distinctive; it constantly earns the city’s pizza stores to point out the various top pizza places within the nation.
Apizza is the traditional Neapolitan-style pizza that commenced in New Haven in 1925. Looking to recreate Naples’ pizza on the streets of New Haven, a person named Frank Pepe commenced promoting slices of pizza from a small shop the front of Wooster Street.
His unique tomato pie was made with Italian tomatoes, olive oil, garlic, and oregano on a signature crust with a sprinkling of grated pecorino Romano cheese on top as the best pizza in New Haven.
Frank Pepe’s nephew, Salvatore Consiglio, opened up his very own pizza place, Sally’s, in 1938. Those businesses released what’s now an iconic New Haven pizza scene.
New Haven-Style Apizza
Like traditional Neapolitan-style pizza baked in a coal-fired brick oven, St. New Haven ct-style thin-crust pizza originated in the 1920s when Frank Pepe opened his first pizzeria on Wooster Street.
When Frank’s nephew Sal Consiglio opened his very own place, Sally’s, at the identical street, a legendary rivalry — and similarly legendary New Haven-style pizza was born.
After the restaurants were joined through Modern Apizza withinside the 1930s, New Haven took on a destination status, and these days pizzerias like Da Legna, BAR, and Grand Apizza keep on the tradition that’s why it is called the best pizza in New Haven.
1. Tomato Pie
The first New Haven pizzas have been topped only with tomatoes and no cheese. Cheese or “Mootz,” entire milk shredded mozzarella, is considered an extra topping. If you order a plain pizza, don’t assume it comes heaped with cheese.
The sweet tomato sauce made simply with crushed San Marzano tomatoes shines on this pizza topped with an imperceptible quantity of freshly grated Parmesan (or Pecorino Romano) cheese because it’s the best pizza in New Haven. It should initially be ordered with or without anchovies.
2. White Clam Pizza
Another aspect New England is known for is its seafood. A white pizza is topped with chopped littleneck clams, generous quantities of garlic, olive oil, grated Pecorino Romano, and oregano. Clams on pizza isn’t a traditional Italian topping. It began at Frank Pepe’s withinside the 1960s, taking benefit from local offerings to use the restaurant’s clams as the half shell appetizer.
The briny, chopped clams, aged cheese, and garlic pair flawlessly with the crispy crust. Some love adding bacon to the pizza for a salty evaluation of the shellfish as it’s the best pizza in New Haven. You can discover clam pizza in different regions outdoor New Haven, including at New York’s Pasquale Jones.
3. What Makes New Haven Style Different from Other Pizza Types?
There are particular sorts of Connecticut pizza indigenous to the New Haven area: plain tomato and white clam pizza. Some eating places specialize in only one variety, however extra of them provide the choice to pick both and customize your toppings.
The first alternative is garlic and Parmesan mixed with a fresh tomato sauce. Make sure that you ask for the “Mootz” pie! If you need mozzarella cheese, you may want to order it because the object is considered a topping in this region.
If you select the white pie, you may acquire garlic, mozzarella, Parmesan, and oregano with an olive oil base. For an actual taste of the best New Haven-style pizza, consider ordering a pizza like this with fresh littleneck clams.
4. Best Pizza in New Haven
4.1. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana is the grandfather of New Haven’s pizza scene. From its humble beginnings on Wooster St new in 1925, Frank Pepe’s pizza has expanded to 5 different places in Connecticut and New York.
Although plenty of time and expense has gone into duplicating the flavor and feel of Pepe’s experience, none comes near the experience of the unique Pepe’s area in East Haven.
Two dining rooms are usually filled to the brim, frequently with long lines trailing down the block. The unique Frank Pepe’s is now referred to as The Spot, placed to the left and rear of Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana stands on Wooster Street. It is home to a more minor, almost equal operation with shorter lines; however, Pepe’s right remains the main draw.
Inside, a vast and deep brick oven with a white-tiled facade stands at attention withinside the rear, attended by white-aproned men wielding impossibly lengthy peels and pounding out their large oblong pies.
Frank Pepe’s first pizzas were tomato pies. A nod to those modest roots is also discovered withinside the constantly-lit “Original Tomato Pie” neon sign hanging higher than the kitchen counter. It’s the best pizza in New Haven.
Hundreds of imitators have tried to match the intoxicating combination of Romano cheese, fresh garlic, olive oil, parsley, and clams atop the chewy and charred rectangular pies.
4.2. Sally’s Apizza
Sally’s pizza is simply down the road from the original Pepe’s in St. New Haven, CT 06510. This cash-only establishment retains its old-school vibe, entirely with a decades-old local argument approximately whether Sally’s or Pepe’s is better. Die-difficult pizza enthusiasts flock to this unique area and declare it’s the best pizza in New Haven.
The most famous menu object is the tomato pie; however, the garden pie with tomato, mozzarella, zucchini, and basil is well worth veering from the traditional
4.3. Bar Apizza
New Haven’s 21 and up pizza spot is a nightclub that still occurs to have darn precise New Haven-style pies with a twist. The bar’s declaration of fame is its mashed potato pizza bacon; order it as a white pie with garlic, mozzarella, and bacon.
Don’t forget about BAR’s signature green salad with pear slices, caramelized pecans, and crumbled blue cheese because it’s the best pizza in New Haven. It’s a decadent combo; however, the thin crust continues you from feeling too weighed down to dance after dining. Come again for an egg-topped brunch pizza at the weekend.
4.4. Zuppardi’s Apizza
The key to Zuppardi’s top-notch pizza? “All things fresh.” We’re speaking high-quality tomato, basil, olive oil, mozzarella, and Pecorino Romano, everything as fresh as they come. Their sausage pie is an element of wonder.
Frank is impressed with their roots in traditional Italian baking and that they use Baker’s Pride gas ovens in preference to coal-fired ovens.
Get your brine on with their fresh-shucked clam, the best pizza in New Haven with garlic and lemon wedges at the side. Run through sisters Laurie and Cheryl, Zuppardi’s is an 80-year-old family heirloom recognized in West Haven for its sausage pie, in which the primary slice is as appropriate because the last.
4.5. Modern Apizza
Located on State Street withinside the East Rock neighborhood, Modern Apizza sits simply off the well-beaten path of Wooster Street, earning its fame within the best New Haven pizza scene with 80-year records and adherence to pizza tradition. Its signature pie is referred to as the Italian Bomb.
Modern’s owner Bill Pustari — who bought Modern from its unique owner over thirty years ago, has worked challenging to build its popularity due to its location. As a result, it is the most welcoming and family-friendly of the massive three.
Modern’s open-flame brick oven cranks out charred, chewy, and great pizza. The extra toppings, the merrier. The crust is one of the more exciting for New Haven pizza, thanks to the detailed texture of its undercarriage.
While a few parlors use cornmeal to assist pizza slide off the peel, Modern uses a unique breadcrumb recipe. Oversee the oven action, and you will see every pizza touchdown on a rough mat earlier than it makes its way right into a pizza box, clearing off the remnants.
The thin and chewy Modern crust results from dough made from a starter, with flour, water, yeast, and salt, then dealt with to a 24-hour cold fermentation.
Modern does now no longer pulls away from its use of cheese, that’s real milk-aged mozzarella, and each Modern pie is completed with a hit of Pecorino Romano.
The sauce is made from whole hand-crushed Italian peeled tomatoes, frequently bought through the lot to ensure consistency, and chefs only at some stage in its time within the oven.
4.6. Da Legna
Da Legna is now being touted as the best pizza in New Haven and the primary competitor to all those oldies in New Haven-style pizza. Why? Because their margarita pie is fantastic!
The San Marzano sauce on it is splendid, with simply the proper quantity of garlic and the best placement of the mozzarella cheese. Additionally, it would help if you tried their blackberry burrata salad, fried calamari, Brussel sprouts, and the Funghi and BBQ di Maiale pizzas.
4.7. Roseland Apizza
It’s a 30 minutes drive west of New Haven’s Wooster Street; however, Roseland Apizza must be within the mix if you need to get your thin-crust pizza fixed while you are in the area.
Located withinside the New Haven County city of Derby, this restaurant has been run by the same family since 1935, and the whole thing they serve right here is over the top.
Both in great and portion size. You will discover the best pizza in New Haven options du jour listed on a “specialty” chalkboard in the back.
Roseland is referred to for its seafood Polsinelli pie topped with a pound of lobster, plus scallops and shrimp. It comes with a piece of a thicker crust and a hefty price tag.
4.8. One 6 Three
One 6 Three is opened in February of 2016. While it’s pretty new at the pizza block and the best pizza in New Haven, it’s grown into one of the nation’s well-known pizza joints.
This small business cranks some exceptional wood-fired artisanal pizzas, sandwiches, small plates, etc.
It prepares brick-oven pizzas fresh to order. And most effective, the freshest, locally sourced ingredients are used.
One 6 Three boasts a relaxed, industrial eating room and bar for the ones choosing dine-in. You get to look right into their bustling open kitchen and watch as cooks unleash their culinary magic.
4.9. Ernie’s Pizzeria
Ernie’s Pizzeria is a family-owned traditional pizza restaurant with a faithful clientele. It’s often cited as the best pizza in New Haven, Connecticut.
Their pies have a chewy and crispy crust; however, without the sourdough flavor related to the likes of Pepe’s.
You can also order gluten-free pies that have a great crust and are in no way oily with tasty Mushrooms on top.
4.10. La Vero Pizza
La Vero is a new eating outlet in the heart of New Haven. It provides and serves Margherita, plain cheese, and chicken pizzas. They additionally serve mouthwatering chicken Caesar salads, garden salads, mozzarella sticks, alfredo pasta, and a steam bomb sandwich.
As one of the most famous counter-serve joints in New Haven, the eating place serves the slice or entire pies. Make sure you taste the fries and shrimp pizza while you go to this restaurant. They’re the most delicious in New Haven town!
4.11. Next Door
This pretty new bar and eating place on 175 Humphrey Street is about far more significant than simply pizza. It’s a brick-and-mortar brainchild of Bodak and Coffin, famously recognized for the Big Green Truck Pizza.
Expanded from a mobile, wood-fired pizza truck business to a complete eating place in June of 2018, Next Door is the proper area to be. It serves the best New Haven Pizza, small plates, additional beer, and different drink specials. They have 3 eating rooms for dining guests.
If you go any night time of the week, you’ll see human beings enjoying meals and socializing. Next Door is an area where communities come together to greet newcomers, exchange suggestions, and study the trendy local news.
The area has a warm and welcoming community feel. This establishment has a massive number of exciting meal options along with innovative pies.
At this joint, you’ll additionally discover a bar with 32 craft beer taps in addition to great cocktails. Visit Next Door and experience brilliant meals, service, and drinks.
4.12. Zeneli Pizzeria
Zeneli Pizzeria at 138 Wooster Street focuses on authentic, proper Naples-style pizza. Pizza restaurant brothers Gazmir, Aleko, Jetmir, and Jeshar, opened Zeneli withinside the distant 2000s. The 4 brothers got here from Naples, a city rich in romantic lifestyle and traditions.
At Zeneli’s, servers usher in clients with an outstanding wood-burning pizza, exceptional salads, and a fantastic dessert as it is called the best pizza in New Haven.
4.13. Abate Restaurant
Gluten-Friendly Pizza Place New Haven: Abate has a massive menu. And we mean huge! And what we like approximately on the menu is the extensive gluten-free pizza section. You can get all varieties of amusing gluten-free toppings lactamases casino, meatball, seafood special, Hawaiian, etc.
They have salads as well. And they deliver! If you’re no longer in the mood for pizza, you may usually attempt a seafood dish; however, do ask your server approximately which ones are safe as it is the best pizza in New Haven.
4.14. York Side Pizza
The locals know York side Pizza and Restaurants as their “one-stop stress consuming area.” Aside from their bestseller broccoli, garlic, and sausage pizza, they’re additionally recognized for their super fries, burgers, lobster rolls, coleslaw, and potato salad for the best pizza in New Haven. But ensure to have a reservation ahead because the place is crowded with families and groups of pals at any time of the day.
4.15. Est Est Est Pizza
The thin-crust pizzas of Est Est Est are the best pizza in New Haven. And apart from its exceptional taste, their unique pizzas are also very budget-friendly and affordable. Aside from pizzas, they also serve tasty pies, chicken wings, salads, cappuccinos, espressos, or frozen yogurts. Plus, in addition, they have gluten-free pizzas for the fitness conscious.
New Haven pizza is a culinary experience that everybody has to try at least as soon as in their lives. Taking the pizza approach would possibly be a bit exceptional at first; however, you’ll additionally find out that the Connecticut version of the world’s most-famous pie is one of the best pizzas in New Haven.
Whether you attempt one with clams, choose more mozzarella, or enjoy something “plain” with Romano, olive oil, and tomatoes, you’ll discover the flavors.
Also, read this article, 10 Best Restaurants in Maui.
Verified Content by Experts
USA Tales has content written by niche experts, travelers, students, and those with real-life experience. Our content is also periodically reviewed by subject matter experts to ensure content accuracy and relevancy. Have a question? Email us at firstname.lastname@example.org