Best Cupcakes in NYC – 10 Must Go Bake Houses

8 mins read
Best Cupcakes in NYC

Every search engine result will tell you that the birthplace of the cupcake was America. The ‘Best Cupcakes in NYC’ is one of the highest searched terms, especially since around 770,000,000 cupcakes are eaten by Americans every year.

A cupcake is a cup-sized cake baked with sweets and topped with frosting.

As per records, the cupcake idea was first mentioned in a cookbook by Amelia Simmons in 1796. However, the term ‘cupcake’ was first referred to in an 1828 cookbook by Eliza Leslie.

Another interesting fact is that American cupcakes are sweeter than other country cakes.  Cupcakes have a special place in the circadian cycle of Americans. Their favorite cupcake savors are chocolate, vanilla, red velvet, strawberry, carrot, etc.

Source: Anna Dr/Shutterstock

The small, delectable piece that gives a pleasant feeling in your mouth as you try to devour it is none other than cupcakes sold in New York City shops. These titbits will fill your mouth with sweetness; you will want to eat a few more if they are available.

The City of New York can boast of several ‘foodies’ and can go crazy over delicious items like cupcakes. There is no need to feel guilty as you dive into the pleasures of the forbidden pastry, and it soothes your mouth.

You can take it with a cup of warm coffee or tea as you relax inside a café and lazily read the newspaper.

There is always a struggle about the name cupcake. Some assert that it is because of its cup size it got the name, while the others squabble it is because of the cupful measurement of the ingredients. However, In Britain, cupcakes are known as Fairie cakes or butterfly cakes.

  • The Hostess Bakery first introduced the cupcake commercially in 1919 as a snack cake.
  • The frosting is the forte of American Cupcakes.
  • It was Winston Churchill who suggested the frosting off cupcakes. 
  • December 15 is reserved to commemorate cupcakes. 

Must-Try: Best Cupcakes in NYC

Here are some of the best cupcakes in NYC.

1. Magnolia Bakery 

Magnolia Bakery always comes on the top list of best cupcakes in NYC. After the two beauties from Sex and the City ate cupcakes from their bakery, it came into fame. And, indeed, cupcakes from Magnolia Bakers never disappoint cake lovers as well.

The high in-demand one is their special cupcake. The other top flavors are carrot cupcake and pumpkin spice cupcake. Magnolia Bakery started in 1996 in the west village of NYC. Today one can find the franchise scattered around the country.

Magnolia bakery’s recipes have not changed much since they started functioning one hundred twenty-five years ago. The Bakery bakes these cakes in small quantities at the same time. Cakes are made from scratches, and the ingredients are most acceptable to the core.

There is a list of fan-favorite cakes and cupcakes, banana pudding, and a selection of classic baked goods, seasonal treats, and more. This bakery started the cupcake craze in the 1990s.

Not only in Sex and the City, but this cake shop also features Prime and The Devil wears Prada. Its business expanded with time, and its first overseas store was opened in Dubai in 2010. Besides its stores in the USA are located in Boston, Washington DC, New York City, Chicago

Banana pudding and vanilla wafers here are the best morsels for hedonistic indulgences.

2. Molly’s Cupcakes 

The bakery was named after a school teacher who was happy to serve flavorsome cakes on her students’ birthdays. You will find some of the best cupcakes in NYC here.

Miss Molly’s special recipe made her cakes unique and tempting.’ The founders of Molly’s Cupcakes did their best to follow the savory. Now the bakery has succeeded in its fame all over the country.

Molly’s Cup Cakes was born when the owner started giving his passion for food a proper shape.

You can never question the store’s customer service. The goods are delivered to your doorstep if you purchase them. You can cater to them for different occasions, whether it is somebody’s birthday, baby shower, corporate events, weddings, etc.

Their top sold cupcakes are Crème Brule cupcakes and Peach Cobbler. Four different flavored vegan cakes are vanilla, chocolate, pumpkin, and carrot Gluten-free, including carrot, chocolate, and vanilla.

Address: 228 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014.

3. Sweets for the Sweeties

“Life is short, make it sweet” is the taste motto of ‘Sweets for the Sweeties.’

Classic Chocolate Buttercream Cupcake, Classic Chocolate Fudge Cupcake, Classic Vanilla Fudge Cupcake, and Specialty Cupcake are ravenous consumption opportunities for one’s appetite. If you’re looking for some delicious treats this is the place for the best cupcakes in NYC.

The cupcakes here are delicious to eat, and customers often praise them for their services and staff. My favorite cake here is the strawberry cheesecake cupcake. The cake is sweet, the strawberry filling is tasty, the frosting is smooth, and you will relish every bite.

The interiors are brightly painted, and if you go inside, you will at once feel light-hearted and carefree; it is fun only if you are exhausted and feel like relaxing

The takeaway facility, classic flavors, and beautiful interior are their highlights.

Location: 210 Hart St, Brooklyn, NY 11206

4. Two Little Red Hens

This shop opened on the Upper East Side, joining a place where Ladybird stands. Apple and Pecan pies, cheesecakes, cupcakes, and blackout cakes are very popular with the crowd that throngs this place at regular intervals.

This place was renovated last year, and it is looking forward to shifting to new premises. You can try making some of these cakes at home but be sure to have a cake board. The baker also cools down this cake before frosting and slicing.

Amazing cream cheese frosting cupcakes in the bakery give the best taste bud experience.
The standout cupcakes made by the culinary experts stop you from going to other cupcakeries. Find some of the best cupcakes in NYC.

The Brooklyn Blackout is enough for the sweet hunters to foray into the place forever. You can find the bakery on the upper east side of York city. The rich, smooth, and dense cupcakes here make anyone addicted.

Location:1652 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028

5. Billy’s Bakery 

Over time Billy’s Bakery has achieved tons of active customers with its authentic flavors and sweet-savory combinations. The distinct aroma from the bakery when you walk in makes it more voracious.

Suppose you are looking for quality dessert; head straight to Billy’s Bakery. The interior of the place is spectacular. The food is yummy, and it tastes delicious as the sweet sensation lingers on your tongue even after leaving the store.

There are fresh peach pies, and as you will also dig into the pastry, you will find that the crunchy and crumbly thing has started melting inside your mouth.

Classic Chocolate Cupcake, Yellow Daisy Cupcake, Banana Pudding, Red Velvet, and plenty more add to the taste buds and make the bakery list of the best cupcakes in NYC.

Where: 184 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011.

6. Sprinkles 

Sprinkles is without a doubt one of the best cupcakes in NYC. The first cupcake ATM at Beverly Hills in Los Angeles in 2005 came from Sprinkle inventions. This 24/7 ATM for fresh cookies and cupcakes is the world’s first cupcake-only bakery.

Sprinkles Bake Shop offers a range of goodies; they are home-baked and taste delicious. Prices are not that high, and you can drop in to taste the baked cakes, cupcakes, pies, and cookies.

There are milkshakes and slush if you want to sip them after a tiring day. The store promises to use the freshest ingredients.  This bakery has over twenty years of experience, and the people working here are engaged in baking and helping customers celebrate life.

Custom-made cakes are the specialty of this shop. The bakers here are diligent; they will always listen patiently to you and then bake a cake that will delight you.

Whether it is a birthday, wedding, or baby shower, their custom-made cakes will always make the guests give you extra credit for choosing them.

Sprinkle cakes can take the sweet pangs on a taste trip. Robust savors and passion make their cupcakes unique. Platterful of flavors is there to boast for them. 

The iconic Red Velvet Cupcake is enough to surge into the universe of Fairie cakes.

Some of the lists from their cupcake store are salted caramel, dark chocolates, black and white, gluten-free lemon blueberry, chocolate marshmallow, and lemon coconut.

Where: 780 Lexington Avenue, NY 10065

7. Buttercup Bake Shop

Lemon cupcakes are the highlights here. Sour Cream Spice Cupcakes, Hummingbird Cupcakes, Lady Baltimore, and Devil Dog are the tongue switchers from your old bakery shops.

The banana pudding tastes fantastic, and the rich and thick pudding blends with fresh banana bites and crushed vanilla wafers that give that crunchy and creamy feel as you try to gulp down this excellent pudding in a matter of minutes. Undoubtedly one of the best cupcakes in NYC.

The cakes also taste great as the soft, moist things are paired with fluffy frostings. These fantastic cakes and pastries will always make you feel like spending an extra dollar as these sweet things roll inside your mouth and uplift your mood.

Buttercup Bake Shop bagged many awards through their delectable and sealed menu.
German Chocolate and Banana Pudding here will make you revisit the cakery.

Location: 973 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022

8. Erin Mckenna’s Bakery 

They can boast about serving friendly and unfriendly bellies alike since every item served here is gluten-free and vegan. This bakery is the best option for people with all allergies, food sensitivities, and cautious health people. 

They use natural sweeteners. Though the bakery is famous for donuts, it is the place for the best cupcakes in NYC for vegans. Their menu consists of vanilla cupcakes, brownies, red velvet cupcakes, etc.

Where: 248 Broome St, NYC.

9. Butter Lane 

Whether it is brunch or a get-together, Butter Lane fixes you with its cupcakes. Rasbery on Vanilla, Caramel on Chocolate, and the Elvis can be your craving comfort cupcakes. Here you will find some of the best cupcakes in NYC.

Sea Salt Chocolate on Banana and Maple Pecan on Vanilla are some of the varieties for food-curious enthusiasts. Monday and Tuesday are their off days.

The ingredients used to make the cakes are natural and fresh. The sugar used is not excessive, so all of it makes for a healthy menu. There are signature base flavors or seasonal base flavors in demand among customers who frequent the shop.

Butter Lane also arranges classes for people who would like to be adept in the art of baking cakes. You can be a baking enthusiast or a friend trying to instruct others; these classes will be fun as you pick up new skills.

Address: 123 E 7th St NYC.

10. Brooklyn Cupcakes

Their eccentric flavors make their cupcakes stand out in the reign of Fairie cakes. This bakery was built on the assurance and implacable commitment of the owners.

 Business in this bakery is a family affair with sisters Carmen Rodriguez and Gina Madera tying up with cousin Michelle Caballero to lend local flavor to the NYC cupcake scene. The natives of Brooklyn gave their Puerto Rican and Italian backgrounds to create recipes that would at once set your heart fluttering and your tongue watering.

The supremacy of their cultural background succors them to amalgamate diversified ethnicities in its culinary – Italian, Polish, Russian, Chinese, Dominicans, and Haitians. Now it has turned out to be one of the bakeries for the best cupcakes in NYC.

The medleys are Tres Leches, Guava, Dulce de Lecue, and Oreo Cheese. Coquito and Tiramisu are the other tempting delicacies.

Hope you find the list of the best cupcakes in NYC helpful. These bakeries thus sell a product whose popularity has gone up and down with time. Cupcakes remain a popular dessert item, but at times, their popularity waned when people of NYC started preferring macarons over cupcakes.

But whether cupcakes can grab the top spot popularity-wise or not, they will smoothen your taste buds, and you will be delighted as pieces of this soft, moist layered edible item satisfy your hunger. Naturally, when we crave something sweet, we can at once hop into one of these eateries.

Click here for more amazing articles like this.

Explore The Exotic Cuisine of New York City
USA Tales

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Latest from Blog

Exclusive Guides & Discounts

Get how-to guides to shopping online, deals on things you love, & starting essentials to launch your business. Discounts when you use our content writing services. More details here.